Republican lawmakers in the US state of Ohio have rejected a bipartisan bill seeking to completely ban child marriage, despite strong opposition from human rights and child protection organisations.
Following a closed-door meeting of Republican members of the Ohio State Senate last Wednesday, lawmakers decided to retain the existing law, which allows 17-year-olds to marry under certain conditions.
Supporters of the current law argue that it contains sufficient safeguards to prevent the exploitation and abuse of minors. However, opponents say loopholes in the legislation have been used to facilitate child trafficking and force underage girls into marriages, particularly in conservative religious communities.
Republican State Senator Bill Blessing, one of the sponsors of Senate Bill 341, which seeks to establish 18 as the minimum marriage age without exceptions, expressed disappointment following the meeting.
“The caucus believes the current law is sufficient. I will try again in the next General Assembly, but I am certainly disappointed,” he said.
The office of Democratic State Senator Bill DeMora, a co-sponsor of the legislation, issued a statement on Thursday, November 19, strongly criticising the decision.
The statement said several members of the Republican majority caucus had blocked legislation designed to protect underage girls from forced marriages, describing the decision as deeply disappointing. It also accused the Republican caucus of hypocrisy.
Both DeMora and Blessing have said they will continue pushing for the legislation. If the bill fails to pass during the current lame-duck legislative session, they plan to reintroduce it at the beginning of the next legislative session.
Meanwhile, Democratic co-sponsor Allison Russo of the Ohio House of Representatives said the failure to pass the bill was difficult to understand, particularly because opponents had not publicly explained their objections.
She noted that during five Senate hearings on the legislation, no members of the general public had testified against it.
Although some Republican senators cited the traditions of Amish and Mennonite religious communities, there was no evidence that these communities had opposed raising the minimum marriage age to 18, she said.
Fraidy Reiss, founder and executive director of Unchained At Last, a national nonprofit organisation working to end child marriage, strongly condemned the Republican lawmakers' decision.
In a statement, she questioned whether Ohio Senate Republicans were uncomfortable publicly acknowledging that they considered a law allowing 17-year-olds to marry sufficient, despite the risks to their human rights.
She added that the organisation would not give up its campaign and would continue pressing for an absolute minimum marriage age of 18, without exceptions.
Last week, several survivors of child marriage shared their traumatic experiences at a press conference outside the Ohio Statehouse.
Stephanie Lowry, one of the survivors, said she was forced to marry a 19-year-old man at the age of 16 after becoming pregnant following her father's death when she was 14.
After the marriage, she experienced physical abuse and became homeless with her child at the age of 17.
However, because she was still a minor, she could not access a shelter or file for divorce before turning 18.
“Putting adult responsibilities on a child without giving them adult rights is not freedom. It is a trap,” Lowry said.
Another survivor, Stephanie Lane, said she married a 31-year-old man when she was 16 and subsequently endured more than two decades of physical, emotional and financial abuse.
Under Ohio's existing law, revised in 2019, a 17-year-old can marry someone no more than four years older, subject to certain legal requirements.
These include a mandatory 14-day waiting period after applying for a marriage licence and approval from a juvenile court.
Before the 2019 amendments, marriages involving underage girls could be legally permitted at any age if the girl was pregnant and the court and parents granted approval.
According to figures from the Ohio Department of Health cited by Unchained At Last, more than 5,000 minors were married in the state between 2000 and 2024.
Meanwhile, Oklahoma and California formally banned child marriage earlier this year. With those changes, a total of 18 US states now prohibit marriage involving minors without any exceptions.
If Ohio's proposed legislation does not pass by the end of this year, the bill will automatically expire.